India-China border dispute: Why India "plays solo" with its counter China

The border stand-off with China has made it crucial for India to rethink all its strategic options. Can it use the growing anti-China sentiment across the world to its advantage? by Pratap Bhanu Mehta, contributing editor on the Indian Express to explain ideas: Why India can’t depend on US & EU to counter China.
June 27, 2020 | 15:38
india china confrontation new delhi admits deploying troops with the same number of opponent troops India-China confrontation: New Delhi admits deploying troops with the same number of opponent troops
india china relation india urgently purchased 33 fighter jets amid tensions with china India-China relation: India urgently purchased 33 fighter jets amid tensions with China
india china border 20 india soldiers killed after clash with china India-China border: 20 India soldiers killed after clash with China
5648 inchi
Indian soldiers keep guard on the Srinagar-Ladakh June 18, 2020. (AP Photo)

The writer says in his latest column that “The degree of global alienation with the Xi Jinping regime is unprecedented. But can this be translated into concerted global action to exert real pressure on China?” and poitns out: "Many strategic experts are salivating at the prospect of India deepening its alliance with the US. In reality, India’s options may be limited.

He also says that: “It is an odd moment in global affairs, where there is recognition of a common challenge emanating from China, but no global appetite to take concerted action.”

Look at the global response to China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). “Many countries are struggling to meet their BRI debt obligations. Many Chinese loans have become a millstone around the debtor countries’ necks. But it is difficult to see the rest of the international community helping all these countries to wean their regimes away from dependence on Chinese finance. Similarly, there are now great concerns over frontier areas of conflict like cyber security and space,”.

1755 chiin
A protests against China in Kolkata (Photo: indianexpress)

Indian diplomacy has traditionally tried to maintain a balance in relations with the US and China

“International relations”, Mehta says, “are formed in the context of a country’s development paradigm”. The US-China relationship for example, may have had its origins in the strategic attempt to create a Sino-Soviet split, “but for decades, this relationship was sustained not by a strategic logic, but by the logic of the political economy of development in both the US and China, where they reciprocally depended on each other”. This US-China arrangement largely benefitted big businesses in America at the expense of its own domestic manufacturing base.

But the political legitimacy of this development model has waned in recent years.

It is still said that so far, India has traditionally not wished to have too close ties with the United States and has tried to maintain a balance in relations with the two US-China powers. But analysts say the bloody confrontation will accelerate India's long-standing strategic pivot toward the United States, said the baoquocte.

The question before India is whether its development needs will fit into the emerging US development paradigm. That is, “Will a US hell-bent on bringing manufacturing jobs back to the US, easily gel with an “atma nirbhar” Bharat?”

Mehta concludes: “We are in a paradoxical world where the strategic necessity of the rest of the world to come together on China has never been higher; yet the appetite for concerted action has never been weaker. Fundamentally, few countries are going to put their money where their mouth is.”

The efforts of the international community will therefore be to try and throw cold water on the India-China conflict as “no one has a serious stake in the fate of the terrain India and China are disputing”.

At the end of the day, Mehta underlines, “India has to manage China and Pakistan largely on its own.”

world news today june 27 over 100 killed by lightning strikes in india World news today, June 27: Over 100 killed by lightning strikes in India

World news today June 27: 120 deaths and over 40 injuries have been reported in a lightning strikes in India. Meanwhile, 13 new COVID-19 cases have ...

can india win us and uks support to refrain china amid rising stand off Can India win US and UK's support to refrain China amid rising stand-off ?

Tension is rising between China and India after the skirmish as both countries are continuing to sending troops to the disputed border and the India ...

india china tensions nail studded iron rod used by chinese soldiers to attack indian soldiers fake or not India China tensions: Nail-studded iron rod used by Chinese soldiers to attack Indian soldiers fake or not?

Images of iron-rod weapons were sent to the media by an Indian officer causing a media storm. He said the weapon was used by Chinese ...

Tarah Nguyen
Phiên bản di động