June 25, 2021 17:07 | About us
Language: Tiếng Việt | ພາ​ສາ​ລາວ | ខ្មែរ | русский | 中文

French court rejected Tran To Nga's lawsuit based on outdated definition

Rosie Nguyen Rosie Nguyen

ngtrang12.ftu@gmail.com

May 25, 2021 | 10:31

This is the view of the lawyers who accompanied Tran To Nga right after the French court turned down her requests for justice for the Agent Orange/dioxin victims.

Agent Orange victims - Fighting for justice Agent Orange victims - Fighting for justice
Swiss Party of Labour voices solidarity with Vietnamese AO victims Swiss Party of Labour voices solidarity with Vietnamese AO victims
Vietnam association for AO victims backs Tran To Nga’s lawsuit Vietnam association for AO victims backs Tran To Nga’s lawsuit
French court rejected Tran To Nga's lawsuit based on outdated definition
Tran To Nga's lawyers made a tough stance after the Crown Court of Ervy city rejected the lawsuit on May 10.

Specifically, the press release of the lawyers of Tran To Nga states:

“Indeed, the judgment of the Evry Court, in which the court declared that it did not accept Tran To Nga's request, was based on an outdated definition of the principle of immunity, contrary to modern principles of international and national law.”

One can only be surprised to find that the court admits that the companies involved appear to have acted out of compulsion by the U.S. Government, when in fact they were only accepting invitations to bid, and thus have the right to free to decide whether or not to do it.

More seriously, the conditions set forth by the U.S. government does not impose a requirement to make a product with high levels of dioxin as found in Agent Orange. It is a purely corporate initiative, a free initiative of the companies concerned.

It is unusual, to say the least, for one motive with multiple implications, the court omitted the same factors that indicate the limits of what companies are allowed to do, excluding any logic of compliance.

At the coming Court of Appeals, it is necessary to give opinions so that the court knows all the contents of the exchanges between the companies and the U.S. Government, which at present, the court only knows a part and it is difficult for them to fully understand. This is so that the court can access all of the information, not just selected pieces of information, which are presented at the request of the companies in a way that benefits them.

The undersigned lawyers argue that justice is on their client's side.

The undersigned lawyers hope Tran To Nga has enough health to cope with the diseases she has so that she can fight to the end!

French court rejected Tran To Nga's lawsuit based on outdated definition

On May 10 2021, the court rejected Tran To Nga's lawsuit. The court said it did not have jurisdiction to judge a case involving the U.S. Government’s wartime actions. Soon after, she appealed.Tran To Nga, 79 years old, owning Vietnamese and French nationalities, suffering illness due to Agent Orange chemicals. In the past decades, overcoming the pain, difficulties, and countless obstacles, she has persistently demanded justice for thousands of Agent Orange/dioxin victims.

The Evry Court's judgment was in favor of the 14 chemical companies, finding that the companies "have sufficient grounds to exercise immunity."

Tran To Nga said she would continue this struggle by leading a march among Paris (France), representing Agent Orange victims against global chemical corporations on May 15 2021.

Her lawsuit states that the law is not an excuse for companies producing Agent Orange/dioxin.

Vietnam War veteran appeal French court ruling on lawsuits against Agent Orange producers

Vietnam War veteran appeal French court ruling on lawsuits against Agent Orange producers

Tran To Nga, an Agent Orange victim herself, sued 14 firms that made or sold the highly toxic chemical. Though her lawsuit was rejected by ...

French court rejects Vietnamese woman’s claim in landmark Agent Orange lawsuit

French court rejects Vietnamese woman’s claim in landmark Agent Orange lawsuit

A French court on May 10 dismissed a case by an elderly French-Vietnamese woman against several agrochemical companies over the use by the US military ...

Agent Orange lawsuit: A plaintiff one million victims

Agent Orange lawsuit: A plaintiff one million victims

Ton Nu Thi Ninh, Vice President of the Vietnam Peace Committee and President of the HCM City Peace and Development Foundation under the city's Union ...

Rosie Nguyen